Operational Design, Taming Wicked Problems, and Lawfare

Abstract:

This paper examines operational design as one aspect of a larger design-thinking domain. Design and designing are firmly established within the literature and describe those actions and endeavours associated with creating form and/or function—the object at the centre of the writers’ attention has a purpose and its purposefulness can be measured objectively. Operational design, on the other hand, is a relatively new term and is used within a military context to describe a form of operational planning that is more attentive to the inner subtleties of an area of interest and necessarily postpones the development of courses of action until after the subject has been thoroughly and comprehensively appreciated. It acknowledges the key characteristics of wickedness and messiness that also frustrate efforts to achieve outcomes in heavily contested social contexts—conflict. In these contexts, there is a rich presence of those who oppose, those who are neutral, and those who support—all must be attended to. Ultimately, all conflict is a clash of wills and a search for asymmetry; operational design and growing the practise of lawfare, therefore, aids the development, sequencing, and execution of least effort activities to achieve specified outcomes. The method presented does not seek to replace current military planning process; it does, however, offer a valuable companion method for situations of great complexity and ambiguity, where imaginative thinking, including the use of lawfare, may be appropriate.


AUTHORS

Photo of Dr. Guy Duczynski

Edith Cowan University
Perth, Australia

Dr Guy Duczynski is a security professional with over 40 years’ military service in Special Operations. In addition to a PhD in operational design, he has an MBA and a Master’s of Education. He is an active  researcher and publisher in a variety of subjects associated with information operations, influence activities, and operations in complex environments.

Photo of Sascha Bachmann

Professor in Law and Co-Convenor National Security Hub University of Canberra
Canberra, Australia

Visiting Research Fellow SIGLA Stellenbosch University
Stellenbosch, South Africa

Sascha Bachmann was educated in Germany (LMU München), South Africa (Stellenbosch and University of Johannesburg) and the UK (Portsmouth). He is an international scholar, former Lieutenant Colonel (GER A Res), with operational experience in the Balkans and as an exchange officer with the U.S. Marines. He is also a career professional in law and higher education. He is currently a Professor in Law at the Canberra Law School and has held other faculty positions at Bournemouth University and the University of Lincoln, after having taught as a Senior Lecturer at the University of Portsmouth. In addition, he was appointed Docent (Reader) in War Studies at the Swedish Defence University in 2016; in 2017, he was appointed (Professorial) Research Fellow at CEMIS, Faculty of Military Science, Stellenbosch University and in 2020 Research Fellow at The Security Institute for Governance and Leadership (SIGLA) at the Faculty of Military Science, Stellenbosch University.

His research is interdisciplinary and discusses topical issues arising from new security challenges of the 21st Century such as hybrid warfare, Information Operations, the use of Lawfare, cyber-enhanced hybrid warfare alongside other topics such as international criminal justice, Lawfare and human security. He has worked with and presented to NATO, US CENTCOM, US AFRICOM, the Austrian Ministry of Defence, the Swedish Defence University, the Royal Danish Defence College, the South African National Defence Force, and the Australian Defence College on the subjects of hybrid war/threats, Lawfare, InfoOps and targeting.

He contributes to NATO’s Legal Advisor Web (LAWFAS) and is a Fellow of NATO SHAPE for the Asia Pacific (Hybrid Threats and Lawfare) working on influence operations, grey-zone, hybrid warfare, great power competition, Australian and Asia Pacific Security. A Fellow of the Higher Education Academy (UK), he is also a regular visiting academic at ADF’s Directorate of Joint Influence Operations.

Professional Photo of Lieutenant Colonel Matt Smith, DSM

Department of Defence
Canberra, Australia

Lieutenant Colonel Matt Smith, DSM, assumed his current position as Divisional G5 this year. Prior to this appointment, he led strategies and concepts at Information Warfare Division and was the former Commanding Officer of Task Group Taji in November 2018. Prior to deployment, he was the Commanding Officer of 1st Regiment, Royal Australian Artillery (2017- 2018). He has also served in a variety of regimental roles within 4th Regiment, Royal Australian Artillery; instructional roles at the Royal Military College; and staff officer appointments in Headquarters 7th Combat Brigade, United Kingdom Defence Intelligence, and Defence Intelligence Organisation. Lieutenant Colonel Smith has undertaken operational service in Cambodia, East Timor, Afghanistan, and most recently in Iraq. Lieutenant Colonel Smith is a graduate of Australian Army Command and Staff College. He holds a master’s degree in Military Studies from the Australian National University, and a master’s degree in Justice of Strategic Intelligence from Queensland University of Technology.

Journal of Information Warfare

The definitive publication for the best and latest research and analysis on information warfare, information operations, and cyber crime. Available in traditional hard copy or online.

Quick Links

View the latest issue of JIW.

Latest Edition

Purchase a subscription to JIW.

Subscribe

Keywords

C

C2
C2S
CDX
CIA
CIP
CPS

D

DNS
DoD
DoS

I

IA
ICS

S

SOA

X

XRY

Quill Logo

The definitive publication for the best and latest research and analysis on information warfare, information operations, and cyber crime. Available in traditional hard copy or online.

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Get in touch

  • Journal of Information Warfare
    21 North Broad Street
    Suite 2-H
    Luray, VA 
    22835 
  • 757.581.9550
  • JIW@ArmisteadTec.com